#AliveWhileBlack: Logical Fallacies and Narrow Mindedness


Yesterday, an acquaintance posted on Facebook,

“Will somebody please tell me when it became OK for people to disobey and disrespect an officer of the law??!?!?”

Rule #1: Some questions on Social Media are rhetorical.

A glutton for punishment, I answered anyway. Early in the thread I tapped away something along the lines of,

“If we’re talking about what I think we are, a quick read of #CrimingWhileWhite and #AliveWhileBlack on Twitter will give you a view of the inequity in the justice system. While it’s never OK to disrespect police, you are much more likely to be killed for it if you’re black.”

I’m paraphrasing here because my comment was deleted, not by me, but not before someone else had a chance to disagree with me.

“Misty sorry but I’d have to strongly disagree with your statement.  It’s so untrue that if you disrespect the police you have a higher chance to be killed if your [sic] black. Where are your facts? [Onus Probandi] I hope not from the tv or the internet [Ad Hominum].”

Let’s call my challenger Amy.  Was Amy right?  Am I a victim of the group-think of my mainly Liberal Facebook friends?

Screen Shot 2014-12-11 at 5.22.01 PM

So I looked around. According to the Bureau of Justice Statistics, read here, of the arrest related deaths between 2003 – 2009, 2,931 were classified as homicide by law enforcement. Of the deaths, 42% of people were white, 32% were black and 20% were Hispanic.

Amy is vindicated!  Except she’s not.

According to the 2010 census, 77.7% of the population is white and only 13% black.  So, are people of color more likely to die during arrest? My husband tried to do the math. My smart mathy friends tried to do the math. Mother Jones does the math here.  Yes, black people are almost 4 times as likely to be killed by police during an arrest.

Screen Shot 2014-12-09 at 8.10.37 PM

I added these links and these stats to the Facebook thread.  Amy said in her husband’s 25 years of law enforcement, he saw no such pattern.  [Appeal to Authority.] I said if we are using her husband’s experience as anecdotal evidence, let’s also use the anecdotes from the #AliveWhileBlack and #CrimingWhileWhite Twitter hashtags. She replied,

“Ya well I don’t go by twitter accounts but good luck with that [Ad Hominum: Appeal to Ridicule]. I go by facts and the statistics that are generated thru the police dept, cities and counties.”

A head spinning response after having offered government generated statistics.

As an aside, Kind Reader, I propose that we retire the dismissive statement, “Good luck with that.” In the spirit of avoiding euphemisms such as, “He has passed away,” or “He has gone to a better place,” just say, “He died.” And instead of “Good Luck With That,” just say, “I think you’re an idiot.”  It is more honest and just as endearing.

Screen Shot 2014-12-11 at 5.02.02 PM

So let’s return to #AliveWhileBlack, stories that plumb much greater depths of racism than I ever suspected existed. And to #CrimingWhileWhite, where caucasian people are acknowledging that they may have gone the way of Tamir Rice or Michael Brown were it not for the color of their skin.

George Elliot wrote,

“It is a narrow mind which cannot look at a subject from various points of view.”



The two Twitter feeds side by side have created a conversation about police bias.  Both sides of the racial divide, prejudice and privilege, are pointing out that the Emperor has no clothes.

It only takes a little reading, a little compassion. Good luck with that? It has nothing to do with luck.








6 thoughts on “#AliveWhileBlack: Logical Fallacies and Narrow Mindedness

  1. I see what Amy is saying, if a police officer receives a call that a crime has been committed, the officer answers the call of the victim, then encounters the alleged perpetrator, the officer ask that the alleged perpetrator stop, the alleged perpetrator stops, obeys the officer’s instructions, is handcuffed and taken to jail. No harm, no foul. The scenarios we have seen recently in our country have taken a turn for the worst, the alleged perpetrator does not comply with the officer’s commands and things escalate from there by the officer and the alleged perpetrator. The result is a deadly outcome. In no way does the skin color of the officer or the alleged perpetrator need to be “the story.” It is tragic whatever the color of the skin from the victim of the crime, to the alleged perpetrator of the crime, to the officer that is called to the scene to do his job to the best of his ability. We are human and all make mistakes. May God continue to bless this great country of ours!!


    1. Bill

      Sometimes methods to apprehend do not go well, especially if an alledged perpetrator has an underlyng medical condition. Of course, if society worries so much about police
      brutality overall, then it might be better to let the alleged perpetrator go free. Better luck a second time, if there is one, and hopefully no one gets hurt.


  2. police are 19 times more likely to be shot by an african-american than by a white person. In light of this fact, your statistics seem to indicate a very reasonable response by law enforcement. Also, a white person is nine times more likely to be assaulted by a black person than the opposite….sad but true…now what?


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s