Weakened, Melting and Pouring Away: When God is Absent

Psalm 22 begins with the psalmist lamenting God’s absence:

My God, MY GOD, why have you forsaken me? Why are you so far from helping me, from the words of my groaning?

God’s absence is enduring:

I cry by day, but you do not ANSWER,

and by night, but find no REST.

The poet describes how abandonment feels in his body: 

I am poured out like water,

and all my bones are RACKED

My heart has become like wax,

DRIPPING out of my bosom. (Ps 22:15)

In Biblical times the HEART was understood to be the CORE of a person’s being. And melting meant WEAKENING. The core of the poet’s being is weakening, melting and pouring away.

Most of us have felt the absence of God in our body, the FEAR when our lives are radically disrupted; by the DEATH of someone we LOVE, the melting of our inner self after a BETRAYAL or a DIVORCE or the loss of a job; the bone-weariness of ADDICTION or mental illness or of full-time caregiving.

The sense that God has abandoned us instills FEAR, fear of how we continue, how we rebuild, whether we will never experience joy again.

I felt this fear, this abandonment, when my father died. My father had raised me, was my closest person. I was only 34, a young mom, and I still needed him. And I remember well-meaning Christian friends who hadn’t lost a parent yet being perplexed by my grief. “But he’s in heaven!” they’d say.

Modern, American Christianity has been tainted by ideas that if we love God enough, if we hope ENOUGH, we will be blessed with unmitigated happiness and material abundance. Some distortions of Christianity mimic self-help formulas, with stigmatizing phrases like, “You don’t need therapy, you just need Jesus!” There are even Christian diet programs to help us “pray the weight away.”

But following Jesus is not a formula for an easy life. And coercive optimism is a cheap knockoff of Christian hope.

The Psalms attest to the realities of our existence, with prayers of petition, praise and thanksgiving as well as prayers of lament, of complaint, as in Psalm 22’s, “Where ARE you???” God can hold our anger at GOD. 

Psalm 22 played a pivotal role in the Protestant Reformation. In the book Here I Stand, a biography of Martin Luther, the Jesus of the middle ages is described as enthroned on a rainbow, waiting to “consign souls to the flames of hell.” (Bainton, Ch. 2)

Medieval Christian culture required a constant, transactional grace, prayers and penances in exchange for indulgences, for reduction of time in purgatory, in the tirelessly negotiated hope of Heaven.

Believers were constantly concerned with the state of their souls. I once thought of Martin Luther as a grumbly German monk with an agenda. But Luther was a human being who struggled with sin and who feared for his salvation.

In the early 1500s, Luther was writing a sermon series on the Psalms. While reading Psalm 22, Luther recognized Jesus’ cry from the cross. 

On the day of his death, after Jesus had been hanging on the cross for 6 hours, he cried out, ““Eloi, Eloi, lama sabachthani?” “My God, my God, why have you forsaken me?” He prayed the first lines of Psalm 22. The God who was first addressed in Psalm 22 by one of His creatures, prayed Psalm 22 as one suffering.

Luther was moved by the thought that Jesus on the cross experienced the extremes of our humanity, emotionally, physically and spiritually.

Jesus’s death was emotional, the shame of being spat upon, derided and mocked, of being executed as a criminal. 

Jesus’ death was physical, his body straining from nails fixed in his feet and hands, the slow suffocation of crucifixion, the sting of blood in his eyes.

And his death was spiritual, experiencing abandonment by God, so desolate, he was alienated from his own divine self.

God took on our being, not just the pleasures of friendship and good food and the beauty of creation, but he took on our every suffering. Even our DOUBT and our sense of ABANDONMENT.

Luther wrote on Psalm 22, “I will say a few words about this ‘being forsaken of God.’––This we cannot understand better than by showing first, what God is! God then is LIFE, light, wisdom, TRUTH, righteousness, GOODNESS, power, joy, 

glory, peace, BLESSEDNESS, and all GOOD! And therefore to be left of God, is to be involved in death, darkness, ignorance, lies, sin, malice, weakness, sorrow, confusion, dismay, desperation, damnation and all evil. . . .” (Luther, 359)

On the cross, Jesus embodied the absence of God, holding in his body all sin and all sorrow.

This offers us an answer to the question we ask ourselves in our darkest moments, the question atheists sometimes ask us when they challenge or dismiss our faith. It is a question I asked working in a trauma center this past year, during the pandemic. People hurt and alienated by the church ask us this. Where is God in all the sufferings of this life?

Sometimes it takes distance to discern. So where was God for me in my father’s death? God’s grace was present in the hospice priest who administered the full Last Rites to my father, “against the rules”, since neither of us knew if my father had ever been baptized.

God was present in my father’s last words to me, and in my friend, Gina, who showed up moments after he died and sat with me for hours.

God was present in the loving witness of the hospice team, who first instilled in me the idea I was called to some sort of ministry, even though I had no idea what that ministry would someday look like.

In those hollow moments when you cry out day and night and find no help, you have entered the mystery of salvation, the narrative of suffering, death and resurrection. Have hope.

In Matthew, we read, “Look, the virgin shall conceive and bear a son, and they shall name him Emmanuel,” which means, “God is with us.” (Mt 1:23)

GOD WITH US. Not a distant judge upon a rainbow. The story of our redemption is a humble GOD who walks beside us, who bore our every trial in his own body, whose own heart melted like wax. Who felt unloved by his father as he was dying. And then, on the third day, rose again.

7 thoughts on “Weakened, Melting and Pouring Away: When God is Absent

    1. Thanks for your comment. Chapter 1 of Matthew is a genealogy of Jesus, and the verses immediately preceding the “Emmanuel” verse read;

      21 She will bear a son, and you are to name him Jesus, for he will save his people from their sins.” 22 All this took place to fulfill what had been spoken by the Lord through the prophet:

      Verse 23 echoes Isaiah 7:14, offering that the birth of this child is its fulfillment, the Messiah.

      23 “Look, the virgin shall conceive and bear a son,
      and they shall name him Emmanuel,”
      which means, “God is with us.”

      “Emmanuel” is a title, or honorific, if you will.

      Thanks for reading.


      1. The genealogy in Matthew extends back to David, to give validation to the claim that He was descended from the royal family. There is another genealogy in the Bible tracing His lineage back through a slightly different line, all the way to Adam, to give validation to the claim that He was ‘of the people.’ Neither of them means a thing, if he was magically sired by God, rather than Joseph.
        The letter J did not exist until the 7th century. The concept was not present in the Hebrew, Aramaic, or Greek languages of His time. The name Jesus could not have been written in the Bible prior to His birth, as a prophecy. Its existence there now, shows that it was added a millennium later.
        The name which later developed into ‘Jesus’ was invented by Paul, after Jesus’ death, when he went to preach to the Greeks. Paul called his savior, Ia-Zeus – meaning ‘son of the most powerful (Greek) god,’ to get Him accepted as part of the Greek pantheon. It could not exist in the Bible as a prophecy.
        While the Greek term “Christos” existed when Paul journeyed there after Christ’s death, he was the first one to apply it to his savior-figure. The Jews would have referred to Jesus as ‘Messiah.’ Evidence seems to show that this entire story was a later fabrication and interpolation. 😯


  1. “Modern, American Christianity has been tainted by ideas that if we love God enough, if we hope ENOUGH, we will be blessed with unmitigated happiness and material abundance. ”

    Tainted? Jesus promised exactly this in the bible. The speech about the lilies, the promises of all prayers asked being answered with what is prayed for, etc. Christians have figured out that those promises were false and now have to make excuses up on why their god now fails.


    1. Timothy Duston

      I think you misread Christ’s words about the lilies (and the birds) in this indictment. That sermon does not promise that the birds and lilies will not suffer through drought or famine or frost. In the same way our lives are marked by tribulation, the birds and the lilies endure through the Grace of God. What is being stated in this thought piece is that modern American Christianity preaches a certain brand of “feel good” theology that ties suffering to unfaithfulness, and the converse, freedom from suffering to hyper-faithfulness. God is not obligated to deliver us from our suffering simply because we ask God to, rather, our hope lies in the faith that our suffering is overcome by Love and Life on the Third Day. The Psalmist laments the feeling of abandonment by God, perhaps, because God does not show up for the Psalmist the way the Psalmist might want or expect God to. Even in Christ’s case, there was not an angelic host to take Him off the Cross. But, thanks be to God that our timeline is not God’s timeline, our perceived abandonment is not true abandonment, and while we might not understand God’s Timing, God shows up for us exactly when God intends.

      Liked by 1 person

      1. Nope, didn’t “misread” it at all, and notably you have nothing to show that I did.

        it is always amusing when a Christian tries to lie to me about what the bible says. Here is what the lilies speech promises. ’27 Consider the lilies, how they grow: they neither toil nor spin;[e] yet I tell you, even Solomon in all his glory was not clothed like one of these. 28 But if God so clothes the grass of the field, which is alive today and tomorrow is thrown into the oven, how much more will he clothe you—you of little faith! 29 And do not keep striving for what you are to eat and what you are to drink, and do not keep worrying. 30 For it is the nations of the world that strive after all these things, and your Father knows that you need them. 31 Instead, strive for his[f] kingdom, and these things will be given to you as well.

        32 “Do not be afraid, little flock, for it is your Father’s good pleasure to give you the kingdom. 33 Sell your possessions, and give alms. Make purses for yourselves that do not wear out, an unfailing treasure in heaven, where no thief comes near and no moth destroys. 34 For where your treasure is, there your heart will be also.”

        Now, do you really want to keep making false claims about your bible? It clearly says that *all* needs will be taken care of.


  2. timothyduston

    It is unfortunate that bitterness and anger so pollute your perspective. You have the audacity to try and spoil something beautifully written with the poison of your ignorance and then to set yourself up as a victim who has been lied to by Christians. No where in your proof-texting (which is wretchedly poor form) does it explicitly state that “all needs will be taken care of.” Rather, Christ offers a promise of sustenance. That is, as we strive toward the mark of the high-calling, as St. Paul puts it, God will sustain us as God sustains the lilies and the grass and the birds. Sustaining our needs and giving us everything we ask for in prayer, which is what your first comment was about, are hardly the same thing.

    There is more exegesis to be done on that, however, my spirit is quickened to offer you these words of Gandalf: “The wise speak only of what they know…therefore keep silent.”


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s